An hour before I started this movie, I told a neighbor, “Let’s see if it’s actually good or if it just had good marketing.” I can tell you with confidence that this movie actually is good, and it’s not just the marketing. I haven’t had much appetite to write reviews lately, but this film felt like it was a rare, unique phenomenon, and was worth a discussion, so you know it comes highly recommended.
Gorgeous, textbook storytelling
All great stories begin with a protagonist who strives to overcome their flaws to achieve their goals, a vision for who they want to be or what they want to do. A great antagonist strives for the same goal, but presents an alternate view, method or philosophy for achieving it. A great antagonist forces the hero to reassess their views and either change or perish. A great director is able to take this core struggle, and set it against any backdrop, and any genre. The great director must also convey ideas, emotions and lessons as nonverbally as possible. The more complex the subject and the fewer the dialogues, the better. A great film is able to guide the viewer through this concepts, stories and struggles without holding our hands or doubling up on information. It runs lean to the themes, and doesn’t waste time with objects, ideas and characters who don’t progress the plot in a meaningful, satisfactory method.
The great director must also convey ideas, emotions and lessons as nonverbally as possible.
-my smartass
Dan Trachtenburg’s Prey is one of these films. A hero who strives to become a great predator, pit against an unstoppable alien who similarly strives to find and kill the greatest predators. We watch as a mouse kills an ant, a snake kills the mouse and the Predator kills the snake. It graduates to a wolf, a bear, and then ugly French trappers. It’s a graceful graduation and demonstration of the Predator’s motivations as simple and straightforward as possible.
Similarly, the hero Naru is shown to be a resilient, incredibly intelligent hunter. She is constantly learning, growing, and adapting to her challenges. When she finds the process of trying retrieving her throwing tomahawk too cumbersome, she attaches to a rope to the handle to easily recall it and adapts to her strengths. The demonstration of Naru’s intelligence is so succinct, it puts Benedict Cumberbatch’s Sherlock to shame. No handholding, no exposition, just cause and affect.
There’s a lot more about this film I enjoyed. The dialogue is sparse, the cinematography is gorgeous, the horror is gory and gratuitous, the action is on par with Captain America: The Winter Soldier, and the portrayal of women is respectful and progressive but not overt. It’s a true action film with a female protagonist without needing to warp a grumpy old man into a woman ala Terminator: Dark Fate.

I really, really liked this movie. At multiple moments I commented aloud how excellent a sequence or visual was. I cannot believe that the Predator series was able to figure shit out and finally deliver a satisfying action film.
8/10.
Hulu needs to work on their fucking subtitles, I swear to god.

Can you clarify about the subtitles? Did you watch in Comanche dub with English sub?
LikeLike
I watched the movie in English with English subs (because I was stuffing my face with doritos). When character speaks in Comanche or French, rather than having an English translation in the subtitles, the complete LOONS at Hulu put a direct transcription of the words spoken. “Como ca va” rather than “How are you doing”. Lucky for me, I’m a super genius who sort of knows some French and none Comanche, so I figured out what was going on using context clues. But still.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m not 100% sure but that might have been intentional? The version we watched left the French and Comanche un-subbed.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hey, maybe it is. I mentioned just how mature and intelligent the nonverbal communication is in this film, and how it does a great job of SHOWING and not TELLING. I’m not actually complaining about the subs because it’s apparent through the context, behavior and actions what’s being said or felt, so maybe not having it spelled out for us is an advantage of this film.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Agree on that point – it’s a great action film for that reason – all show not tell.
LikeLiked by 1 person